THE BAD
-The new GL just feels wrong. The strong-ammo nades explode on impact and the regular discs have too much gravity. The old GL felt GREAT, even if it was a "spam" weapon. The effective GL was one of the many things that made the weapon balance stand out for me. IMO i think you should just bring back more or less the 0.32 incarnation, but at the very least you need to ditch the change to the strong ammo projectile. Right now strong ammo disc just feels like a RL shot with gravity. If you fix anything in 0.41, FIX THIS!
-Listing maps by their actual names is a random, and somewhat annoying change. Now you have to scroll through the unorganized list of names and click on each one to determine their gametype. Bring back the old system. It made alot more sense. Also the scrollbar is broken. Maybe add a toggle for mapnames vs the "quake-style" labels.
-wdm15 looks worse than the test version. It's too dark and doesn't look as good as it used to IMO. Fortunately you can import the old version. (although theres one glitched texture on the boxes upstairs)
-Was the jump height reduction really necessary?
-Several options in the menu that were present in previous versions have been removed such as "show fps", "show speed", "marks on wall" ect.
-A couple of the new maps fail to live up to the level of quality present in 0.32. Poor ammo placement, flow, ect.
-Various graphical glitches throughout the maps, the most obvious being wca1.
-There should be an option or console command to switch to the old explosion effects. Some people do not like the new marks.
-Plasma Gun still seems a bit on the weak side
-The new render updates are impressive, but I think there should still be maps in the vein of Acid's wdm2 as far as artstyle. Like many have said before, some of the maps look a bit washed out and lacking in color.

I only look at negatives cuz thats how I was raised.

-Was the jump height reduction really necessary?

-Maps by actual names is a bad choice. The filenames have the gametype they're for in the name so people can at least figure it out. Please bring back filename sorting.

Did you actually try clicking on a map? If there's a recognizable gametype pattern in mapname, the UI will suggest a gametype in status bar.
I figure that people that complain about the new maplist UI didn't actually try using it, it was like "ZOMG!!!11 NO FILENAMES!!!11 WTF?!!!11 CLOSE!!!11", so what the hell.

Once new players learn how to type 'callvote map' they can't be viewed 'new players' anymore.

How does a pure UI issue relate to item spawn times, advanced movement, strategy, whatever? Please enlighten me.
Btw, if you want somebody to focus on your points do not call them nonsensical in the same sentence.

Once new players learn how to type 'callvote map' they can't be viewed 'new players' anymore.

Btw, if you want somebody to focus on your points do not call them nonsensical in the same sentence.

Lets focus on the points I made about the illogical and unintuitive map list, instead of dodging them and making nonsensical comments.

THE GOOD
+Rocket balance is OUTSTANDING, Don't change a thing!
+wdm11 is a great addition the the maplist, very reminiscent of ztndm3 (Blood Run)
+The new wdm6 looks great! While I was initially skeptical about the art change, the new textures are A+
+The engine optimizations ARE noticeable. The framerate is much more stable and the action is fluid and smooth.
+The new movement may feel different at first, but with cg_oldmovement 1 the game plays faster than ever before.
+The improved dash is a nice touch.
+Shotgun arc is an improvement
+Dash animations = great
+Mac OSX support
+Bobot is a great addition to the cast of characters. He is probably my favorite model.
+The graphical profiles are a great touch
+The tutorials were very much needed, considering how hard Valve fanboys find it to pull off simple strafe jumping.
+Instagib is cool

THE BAD
-The new GL just feels wrong. The strong-ammo nades explode on impact and the regular discs have too much gravity. The old GL felt GREAT, even if it was a "spam" weapon. The effective GL was one of the many things that made the weapon balance stand out for me. IMO i think you should just bring back more or less the 0.32 incarnation, but at the very least you need to ditch the change to the strong ammo projectile. Right now strong ammo disc just feels like a RL shot with gravity. If you fix anything in 0.41, FIX THIS!
-Listing maps by their actual names is a random, and somewhat annoying change. Now you have to scroll through the unorganized list of names and click on each one to determine their gametype. Bring back the old system. It made alot more sense. Also the scrollbar is broken. Maybe add a toggle for mapnames vs the "quake-style" labels.
-wdm15 looks worse than the test version. It's too dark and doesn't look as good as it used to IMO. Fortunately you can import the old version. (although theres one glitched texture on the boxes upstairs)
-EDIT: Was the jump change really necessary?
-Several options in the menu that were present in previous versions have been removed such as "show fps", "show speed", "marks on wall" ect.
-A couple of the new maps fail to live up to the level of quality present in 0.32. Poor ammo placement, flow, ect.
-Various graphical glitches throughout the maps, the most obvious being wca1.
-There should be an option or console command to switch to the old explosion effects. Some people do not like the new marks.
-Plasma Gun still seems a bit on the weak side
-The new render updates are impressive, but I think there should still be maps in the vein of Acid's wdm2 as far as artstyle. Like many have said before, some of the maps look a bit washed out and lacking in color.

THE VERDICT: After eight months of anticipation, the WSW team has delivered another masterpiece, marred only by surprising technical glitches and a disappointing grenade launcher.

astsmtl wrote:

I think it would be not so hard to make a two-column sortable table with both filenames and map names.

You think wrong